I think what you are hearing is old info from the original Floats. The newer Evols are much improved over the original, better seals, better valving and internals. I've never had to add air to any of my Floats, my Evols X's still had the same air pressure in them this fall as they did when I last rode in May. Air temp will affect the air pressure though, you will lose 1 psi for every 10 deg change in temp. So if you adjust the pressure in your warm garage at 70 degs and then ride in 10 deg temps, you will lose 6 psi of air pressure in the shock. So you have to adjust for that temperature difference.
There are several extreme back country riders that use FOX air shocks, Quinlan, Kyle, Brown and Olzenak to mention a few, they aren't complaining about them. If they can drop 100' cornices, I'm sure you and I can not damage them.
Air shocks use air to replace the springs, so you use air to adjust the ride just as you would spin the adjuster on you springs - shock are adjustable - you're supposed to adjust them. Problem is most people have no clue how to adjust them properly, and thus they complain about how crappy a shock is because they don't understand what's wrong or how to correct it.
Here's a guide I put together several years ago to help people understand how to adjust their air shocks, if you don't adjust them properly then they obviously won't perform properly. All pressure has to be off the shock to make adjustments, so elevating the sled or rolling the sled over on one side needs to be done to make adjustments to the air pressure.
Don't listen to rumors, get actual real world experience from people that own them and now how they work.
Evol Chamber controls the bottom out resistance (0-300 psi range) Set 1[sup]st[/sup].
- If traveling to quick through travel, increase press by 10 psi
- If not using full suspension, decrease press by 10 psi
Main Air Chamber adjusts the ride height (sag), roll/pitch stiffness (0- 150 psi range) Set 2[sup]nd[/sup]
- Adjust by 2 psi to rise or lower spring force Ride height)
Temperature Dependency = 1 psi per 10 deg change
Clickers. Adjust 2 clicks at a time, full in (clockwise) is #1
Compression Red knob
- Clockwise stiffer
- Counter clockwise softer
Rebound Blue knob
- Should return as fast as possible with out bucking
- Clockwise is slower rebound
- Counter clockwise is faster
- Too much rebound dampening will seem harsh, washout, & packing
Tuning suggestion:
As a general rule you want as little rebound damping as possible so that the suspension returns quickly, but still enough rebound damping that the front of the snowmobile does not oscillate upon landing. The front of your snowmobile should return quickly to ride-height and then remain still. If the front suspension continues to oscillate several times after landing, try increasing rebound damping (slower).If the suspension does not oscillate after landing, try decreasing rebound damping (faster).This procedure should allow you to close in (or bracket) on the desired rebound damping setting
Symptoms of Too Much Compression Damping
The front end is harsh over small bumps. Shock seems to stay almost rigid instead of absorbing bumps. Especially noticeable on downhill bumps.
The front end is harsh at high speeds over large or medium bumps. The shock stays too rigid and does not use enough travel to absorb bumps. The shock rarely or never seems to bottom-out, even off the biggest jumps.
Symptoms of Too Little Compression Damping
The shock bottoms-out on medium-sized bumps and at the bottom of deep, smooth gullies, or rising portions of deep, rolling whoops.
At high speed the front end takes medium square-edged bumps smoothly, but bottoms out too easily on larger bumps. Bottoms out too easily off jump and at high speeds over large square-edged bumps.