I'm hesitant to write this, but also in a way glad to try and explain my feelings on the G4/G5 sleds. Tieing into
@bdlenhart 's question a bit about why I don't own a G4/5 and upgrade it like I do with the other sleds and well, that's because I already did it. The abridged version of it is that I truly feel the G4/5 bulkhead and the resulting geometry/chassis dynamics were a miss, especially when compared to the previous XS chassis. Doo has since made several bandaid's to try and fix things, but they've gone so far that when I ride G5's now, they feel numb to me, I feel like there's a disconnect between myself and the machine. That's the short version.
Long version, this has a lot of back story but explains my disdain for current Doo stuff:
When i got back into sleds after racing, it was a 2011 XP, then a new 2015 XRS 120", shortly after my father and I split a low mileage 2017 850 w/ the late spring order KYB pro40 option that a guy in NY was selling mid season. That sled was the most nervous, unpredictable thing we've probably ever owned...UNLESS...you were hammering 2' moguls or riding tug hill on a Saturday afternoon, in those conditions it was untouchable...until it blew a belt. If anyone goes back in the Dootalk archives or had a 17/18, they'll remember how awful those things were in the front end predictability/confidence department. Que up the grand touring swaybar, shorten the shocks, dump the spring rate so it sits 3/4 into the shock stroke crowd here.
I did some simple stuff to that thing but it was just not right. I'll try to shorten this middle ground up a bit, I rode some Polaris Axys sleds at the NY snodeo back when they had demo rides and was sold on the front end alone, just having a seating position similar to the G4 but a front end that worked was all i needed to jump ship. I then rode a '19 Indy 850, the following year ordered a 2020 XCR and it was an absolute lemon. I'd then ridden a 900T in our group and liked the 4s power and even with the '19 front end. The heavier 900T engine was enough weight, low enough in the chassis, to help correct the roll couple a bit so i said "ehhh maybe i'll try one of these again". Ended up trading the lemon 2020 XCR back to the dealer and picking up a holdover '19 900T.
I absolutely loved that sled for a couple seasons. I threw the Ras-X arms on it with stock length shocks and that combined with the weight/CG and new roll couple was enough for me to be content with the front end for a while. I ended up going a bit too far with that sled for VT trails, I had Whalen make me a very spicy max effort stock turbo tune, gearing options were limited unless you wanted one of Martin's gears so I stuffed 9T 2.86p drivers in it and 8" rear wheels all into the stock 137" track, worked with Ian at Monster and had triple adjusters and what not blah blah blah. I didn't like the current market offerings so built my own exhaust and charge tube/recirculating bov setup.
That was all great until we did the VT border to border in a day ride and i realized it was just too much sled for VT and what not. Now we get into trying to make the Doo's work. I was still mad at the 2020 XCR experience but wanted a 2s again, so I found a 2018.5 600R for cheeaappp (cause the guy didn't currently have the title but he did come through with it like he said) and I set out to make the front ends on these things work. The rear as we all know, with the standard R-motion was and is incredible (R-motion X is a dog) so I didn't need to do much there.
This was the start of the 2022 season and A7 on here had dabbled with really tall (2020+ i think) spindles on I think it was a Freeride or maybe a back country and that was a similar direction to how I wanted to go so I started poking around parts diagrams and what not. To shorten this up, I ended up using 2018 RS spindles, RAS-X arms and 18.5" long shocks to correct the front end geometry to where I thought it would be acceptable. My full 600R build thread with all of this in depth can be found here:
https://www.dootalk.com/threads/600r-rough-trail-build.1613935/
I went nuts with this sled, and it was simply incredible. If there were a sled I wish I hadn't sold, it might be this one. Anyone that rode it was blown away and I honestly don't know if ever ridden a better combo suspension compliance wise. The front end was and is the best Doo setup I've ridden to date, and I've ridden everything but the new G5 4 stroke/Renegade front end.
It worked so well, that I decided I had to try it on a BackCountry to see if it actually was the corrected geometry or if it was just a lucky combo and the Elka's were doing all the work.
Copied the setup onto a 2020 BCXRS but with 18.75" Kashima Pro40's from Ian, all else was the same...'18RS spindles & RAS-X.
The whole setup worked again. Now the BCXRS still took a bit more effort to ride and the rear C-motion skid wasn't
great...but the front end worked. I then rode these for the season. The 900T sat around and eventually got sold. I rode friends sleds here and there and every time I threw a leg over my buddies Matryx, something about it just
felt more exciting even though it wasn't nearly as compliant in the suspension department...but my doo was on Stage 5 elka's so I figured i could work with the suspension on the Polaris.
I was also frustrated that I, me, a 30yo ******* in VT was able to make a front end work, but Doo was doing basically nothing at the time to update these things and make them what they could be.
The downfall to the front end was increased ski pressure, big time...so I could see that for the masses, this front end wasn't a perfect solution...but look at what we have now...
Doo then took anti-squat out of the rear skid to calm the sleds roll axis down in an attempt to keep the front end more neutral and predictable but we all know how that was received. Almost everyone I know puts the front arm in the "more transfer" setting trying to get back to what we had. They just kept throwing little bandaids at it until we now essentially have a very similar setup to what I've got pictured above.
I had been debating going back to a Polaris for the tail end of that '22 season despite having the above wild 2s sleds built...they worked incredibly well, but somehow just weren't exciting to ride. Polaris released the Boost and 5min into the release video I had an order submitted and that was that.
Bring us to present day, I setup and ride G5's and just can't believe how numb they are. I know and completely understand that there's a good portion of riders that want something like this, where it just does the things, but that's simply not me, maybe some day, but not currently. So that's a big one, well the main one, but also....WHY are we still using a tunnel wide enough for a 16" wide track? The sleds feel SO wide if you hop on after a Matryx or Catalyst. Anywayyy, I needed a 4S to go do saddlebag rides in Canada and there was no way I was going to a G5 or another G4 just to dump 5k into it. A 2016 1200 fell into my lap last season and it made me fall in love with the XS chassis all over again. I said it in my saddlebag trip video, I can't fathom how Doo HAD that XS chassis & 1200 combo and then wound up where they are now. I've thought about stuffing a 1200 into a G4 with the front end and all that and I just go "Why? Why even try when the XS is just already IT.".
Anyywaayyy, very long winded, but that's why I'm not dabbling with Doo's much on the personal side of things. I love my 1200 and will be working with that a good bit this season, but not many still care about the 1200's sadly.
All that said, if I had to build a G5 for myself, or if anyone gave me a sled and a checkbook and said "make this as good as it can be"...this is what I would do: 850 n/a, TRA or P85 conversion, hell even a PB80, anything but the p.drive, DooDoctor floating secondary, 128" previous era R-motion (not the X), RAS-X arms, 18.5" Elkas & the new Renegade/4s RX spindle because that's the one. That spindle is sweet, all the benefits WITH the steering leverage to help combat the increased ski pressure this setup gives.
@Baron I'd be way more likely to own a Lynx before a G5 Doo. The Lynx is actually fun to ride, but you have to ride it constantly, which I don't mind, you just need to know that going into your day haha. I'd still make some front end changes, which I think we've discussed via PM before, but as a whole the package is a lot more raw and has an attitude/characteristic too it that just makes it feel like
something...I don't know exactly how to word it, but I'd bet you know what I mean. The main downfall that comes to mind, is strictly a personal one and it's that I have a hard time not destroying the insides of my knees (where my suit doesn't have padding) on the tapered/rounded side panels, and that's my biggest deterrent with the Lynx sleds honestly.