Ski-Doo Snowmobiles Forum banner

Why I spring-ordered a Polaris over a Skidoo for the 1st time

23K views 133 replies 64 participants last post by  bigbellyboom00  
#1 · (Edited)
I will preface this by saying I purchased a 2023 MXZ Blizzard 850 and it was a blast to ride this winter! I am also keeping it for next winter, but was looking to get back to a 600-class sled again. The 850 is a fantastic motor, but to be honest, it is more power than I can reasonably manage on the trails that I typically ride. An MXZ 600 is probably the sled that should be my primary ride for the future, but when I was thinking about what I really wanted in a sled, the scale was tipped to Polaris.

It came down to a MXZ-X 600 package and an Indy VR1 650, and here is why I opted for the VR1:

1. The front end and balance of the Polaris in the corners is reportedly better and lighter than Skidoo. I have learned to manage the heavier feeling of the Doo front end, but I wish it was not so much work. I have owned 3 other Polaris brand motorcycles (Victory and Indian) that were so well balanced, they become part of you when navigating in turns and corners. It sounds like the sleds are engineered with the same type of a rider balance minded approach.
2. The 650 is built to have more low-to-mid speed range torque, with a little more HP over the 600R, and I have not been a fan of the jerkiness of the 600R at low speeds. The Polaris 650 is reportedly very smooth. The 600R has lots of power, but for people who want a little more (but don't want the 850), a 670 or 700 motor would have hit a sweet spot. Skidoo has not responded to the Polaris 650 yet, so no other options with them.
3. Polaris seems to have figured out their hand warmers better than Skidoo, especially with their auto sensing system. I also hate the new left side control block of Skidoo and the new thumb/grip warmers are a pain for trying to regulate. I should not have to think so much about the hand warmers, so I am looking forward to the smart warmers system.
4. The 7S display is exactly what I want for GPS function, the right size screen for easy viewing, it is positioned higher up in the dash area for better vision alignment with eyes on the trail, and from what I have seen, is also easy to navigate between the display functions. When looking at the new 10" Skidoo display, it sits down lower, kind of behind the handlebars, the GPS function must be connected to a phone, and you can only use the BRP GO mapping. The 10" display is only offered with the 850 or 900 turbos, which is disappointing for those riders who choose a 600 sled. I have also been a fan of the Ride Command App on my phone for the past few years.
5. Polaris offered a 3 year warranty!

I realize I am taking a chance with the Polaris (due to concerns about reliability), and it is more expensive than a Skidoo (apples to apples on features), but Polaris is offering key things that appeal to me for what want in a sled at this point of my life. I am also keeping my Skidoo because I know and trust their reliability, and because I am still a big Skidoo fan. In some ways it was hard to make a decision to choose a different brand, as I have been a passionate and loyal Skidoo rider for a long time. This time around, Skidoo simply was not offering enough of the right things for me to spend $15-$17K on a new sled with them. Just thought I would share my journey and will comment on comparisons next winter. No matter what, I am excited to try something different!
 
#2 ·
I love skidoo, but it is nice to change it up once in awhile. Rarely do people trade their car/truck for the exact same one.

Technically I did the same thing as you, but it was more to help the dealer by me out then it is realistic I’ll actually purchase it when it comes in. The sled came out to just a click over 20k and that’s beyond my “yea sure I’ll try it.”

I think people get better respect for what they own by trying another make. In the end it’s not like you’re married to it.
 
#3 ·
Be very interested to hear your thoughts after a season, I really want to try a 650. When I get on my buddies axys and vr1 I just don't see the crazy light steering between that and my G4. It feels a touch lighter but honestly not a huge difference to me or them. Seating position is similar, with vr1 a touch more comfortable for me being 6'2. Rear suspension and overall ride IMHO way more comfortable on Doo. Reliability, I'm not gonna throw stones but I will say on my buddies 17, 18 and 21 there have been a lot of issues. I hope yours is trouble free and if the 650 is noticably better then the 600r that is awesome as the 600r is a great motor.
 
#5 ·
^^Agreed. I do think this is an important post by Old Doo because it shows Polaris is driving hard in the right direction and is starting to offer tempting features.

Voting with your wallet is powerful, it is hard to attract someone to switch brands. Very interesting to hear Old Doo's logic.

I'm a late adopter, we prefer to stick with what's proven, but things like the erratic approach 'doo has had to gauges and handwarmer controls shows Polaris is giving them fits.
 
#8 · (Edited)
Your gonna love it, I had two 1200 Enduro's, they were great, or so I thought, spent the last 2 seasons on a '22 XCR 850, awesome sled, 7S is awesome, brakes, awesome, hand warmers are awesome, ergo's and front end awesome, rear was great to, I like wheelies and bumps and the sled could hammer them, 3900 trouble free miles, Just ordered a 24 Lynx Rave RE cause again I like wheelies and awesome shocks, and the Lynx looks to deliver, I am upset about the lame gauge and left hand controls but I can look past that, its the performance I'm after in the end. I have ridden the 650 and it's a very smooth and powerful motor, and the Polaris are so easy to service, hood and panels off in under a minute, no tools. I can't wait to here your reviews, enjoy.
 
#9 ·
Let me preface this by saying I purchased a 2023 MXZ Blizzard 850 and it was a blast to ride this winter! I am also keeping it for next winter, but was looking to get back to a 600-class sled again. To be honest, the 850 is a fantastic motor, but it is more power than I can reasonably manage on the trails that I typically ride. An MXZ 600 is probably the sled that should be my primary ride for the future, but when I was thinking about what I really wanted in a sled, the scale was tipped to Polaris.

It came down to a MXZ-X 600 package and an Indy VR1 650, and here is why I opted for the VR1:

1. The front end and balance of the Polaris in the corners is reportedly better and lighter than Skidoo. I have learned to manage the heavier feeling of the Doo front end, but I wish it was not so much work. I have owned 3 other Polaris brand motorcycles (Victory and Indian) that were so well balanced, they become part of you when navigating in turns and corners. It sounds like the sleds are engineered with the same type of a rider balance minded approach.
2. The 650 is built to have more low-to-mid speed range torque, with a little more HP over the 600R, and I have not been a fan of the jerkiness of the 600R at low speeds. The Polaris 650 is reportedly very smooth. The 600R has lots of power, but for people who want a little more (but don't want the 850), a 670 or 700 motor would have hit a sweet spot. Skidoo has not responded to the Polaris 650 yet, so no other options with them.
3. Polaris seems to have figured out their hand warmers better than Skidoo, especially with their auto sensing system. I also hate the new left side control block of Skidoo and the new thumb/grip warmers are a pain for trying to regulate. I should not have to think so much about the hand warmers, so I am looking forward to the smart warmers system.
4. The 7S display is exactly what I want for GPS function, the right size screen for easy viewing, it is positioned higher up in the dash area for better vision alignment with eyes on the trail, and from what I have seen, is also easy to navigate between the display functions. When looking at the new 10" Skidoo display, it sits down lower, kind of behind the handlebars, the GPS function must be connected to a phone, and you can only use the BRP GO mapping. The 10" display is only offered with the 850 or 900 turbos, which is disappointing for those riders who choose a 600 sled. I have also been a fan of the Ride Command App on my phone for the past few years.
5. Polaris offered a 3 year warranty!

I realize am taking a chance with the Polaris (due to concerns about reliability), and it is more expensive than a Skidoo (apples to apples on features), but Polaris is offering key things that appeal to me for what want in a sled at this point of my life. I am also keeping my Skidoo because I know and trust their reliability, and because I am still a big Skidoo fan. In some ways it was hard to make a decision to choose a different brand, as I have been a passionate and loyal Skidoo rider for a long time. This time around, Skidoo simply was not offering enough of the right things for me to spend $15-$17K on a new sled with them. Just thought I would share my journey and will comment on comparisons next winter. No matter what, I am excited to try something different!
I think you will really like the 650 motor and will warm up the the handling characteristics of the Polaris. I bet you will find this list grow as you ride it. I loved my 650 that I had back in '21, very strong and smooth motor. It's fun trying new things, life is too short to be riding the same thing year after year. I'd probably quit the sport if I only had to ride one brand.
 
#10 ·
In my opinion, you don’t need to excuse yourself. You have obviously got solid reasons and it has been said before - BRP is starting to get little bit too big for their own and their customer’s best, thus the best thing that can happen is that they lose little bit market share to other manufacturers.

Refreshing to read about somebody that dares to make the move instead of just talking about it…
 
#11 ·
I certainly was not trying to write an excuse for why I chose a Polaris over a Skidoo, but I think what is coming out in my post is the passion I have for Skidoo, yet the internal struggle for choosing a different brand. I have looked at Polaris improvements over the past 3 years with interest, but kept riding only Skidoo. It was time for me to make a change and try something new that appealed to me!
 
#23 · (Edited)
I have been on Doo 4 strokes since 2010, averaging 5-6000 miles a year. NOTHING more reliable than these sled. That being said, I ordered a 650 Polaris last year and put over 3000 mile on it with NO issues. I can ride that sled 250 miles a day and not be tuckered out at the end of the day, cant do it on the Doo 4 strokes any more. 16-17 mpg, 190 miles to a qt. of oil, and a 11.5 gal tank.

Handles great, rides great, gauge is top notch. I am not going to say its built as good as the Doo, but pretty close and getting closer. Rode my Doo 500 miles this season, and dont see it getting much next year. Now I have to go and tear the Polaris apart to clean the water out of the bearings before next season, a small price to pay. LOL
 
#29 · (Edited)
I was looking at the Polaris Indy Voyager 650 155 in comparison to the tundra lt 600 efi. There're definite advantages to Polaris, the voyageur power band is more balanced, however the tundra floats better but the Voyageur reverses better than the tundra. The Voyageur is a-arm ski suspension so better balance on trail but worse off trail on more flat land. The Tundra hauls a-lot more, however it's considerably heavier than the Voyageur. Also the Voyageur is better on gas and oil than the tundra lt 600 efi. Quite a bit better in fact. The tundra lt can turn on a dime as the saying goes.
 
#35 ·
I think you’ll be happy with the VR1. I’ve spent some time on a 21 VR1 and a 22 XCR 136 (I think?) both with the 650. Warmers, gage (if you’re into that which you are), and front end will all meet your expectations.
I did find that that 650 feels lively in the mid range, almost like a 125 2 stroke. I think my wife’s 600R is feels stronger off the bottom.
No quorums with the 650, May out her on one soon for just the front end. The 22 I rode seems to load up if idled on cold start and almost needs to be cleaned out like an old sno x sled or ridden hard immediately.
Enjoy!
 
#43 ·
22 years on Ski-Doo's and l made the switch to Polaris for '24 for many of the same reasons as Old Doo Daddy stated. I was simply getting bored with Ski-Doo and needed a rejuvenation. I was contemplating a Polaris for the last 2 years and finally took the jump. I've been riding since 1986 and this will be my 27th new sled and l can't recall a time when I was this excited for the next snowmobile season to get here...except when l bought my new 1990 lndy 650[emoji16]

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk