Ski-Doo Snowmobiles Forum banner

3/4" and 1" Drive Socket Sets - Best Value?

2.8K views 23 replies 16 participants last post by  SKIDOZER500  
#1 ·
What is the best value for 3/4 “ and 1” drive socket sets? I realize this will likely end up like most oil threads, but I am curious as to others thoughts, especially the diesel and heavy equipment mechanic types on here.

As I have gotten more and bigger equipment, I am in the market for some ¾” and 1” drive socket sets. I have been just buying sockets as needed for certain projects, but it is beyond time to just buy a set. I am thinking about a six-point impact set and a 12-point set, both SAE and metric. I have needed quite a few 2”, 2 ⅛”, 2 ¼” and 50-55 mm sizes lately.

Our snowmobile club could use some big socket sets for working on the equipment.

I have no problem paying for quality and have a lot of Snap-On stuff, but I do not know if I need to spend the coin on Snap-On stuff - for me possibly, but not for the snowmobile club (and we could not afford it, anyhow).

I have long subscribed to the idea that - “The bitterness of poor quality remains long after the sweetness of low price is forgotten.” - Benjamin Franklin - and I would rather pay more to not have the frustration of a rounded fastener, broken socket, socket that is too thick to fit or whatever when you are trying to repair something. I know first hand that “if the wheels ain't turning, you ain’t earning”...

I have been buying some Gearwrench stuff lately and it seems decent for the price, but I have not had to use their warranty.

I usually cannot stomach walking into a Harbor Freight, but I know some of their ICON stuff is OK.

With so many brands on the market nowadays, especially with all the Amazon Chinesium brands, I am just wondering what everyone’s experience is.
 
#6 ·
In my trade, (retired industrial mechanic) I bought a {before HF} cheaper 3/4" set and swapped out the ratchet with a Snap-On ratchet head and a pair of handles. I still have the set today and never broke a socket.
 
#3 · (Edited)
I don't have any "sets" that large, but I doo have individuals that are adding up to a full set these days. Many times I just buy a good used name brand, but if I was buying new, I typically buy "Wright" brand sockets. They are Yank, seem to have a good price, and I can't think of any time that I have ever had an issue with their quality on any tool? And some of my 3/4" sockets are Wright for sure, as well as breaker bars and ratchets I think.

I am a stickler for Yank and good quality. I have several Mac tool boxes around the shop, and only good stuff in them.


Edit: I guess I lied, my 3/4 ratchet and breakers are Snap-On and Slip'n'Kill

.
 
#8 ·
I don't have any "sets" that large, but I doo have individuals that are adding up to a full set these days. Many times I just buy a good used name brand, but if I was buying new, I typically buy "Wright" brand sockets. They are Yank, seem to have a good price, and I can't think of any time that I have ever had an issue with their quality on any tool? And some of my 3/4" sockets are Wright for sure, as well as breaker bars and ratchets I think.

I am a stickler for Yank and good quality. I have several Mac tool boxes around the shop, and only good stuff in them.


Edit: I guess I lied, my 3/4 ratchet and breakers are Snap-On and Slip'n'Kill.

I have heard that Wright brand tools is good stuff, I always seem to have trouble finding anyone who actually sells them, even online.

There are so many "brands" on the market nowadays, especially with all the box stores having their brands like Northern Tool = Klutch, Home Depot = Husky, All the Amazon stuff like Tekton.
 
#7 ·
I tend to buy pretty much any old impact sockets for the 3/4" stuff that I have and have not had any issues. Being 6 point stuff, that seems to help avoid cracking a socket.

But like above, I get a good brand breaker bar and rachet. When you really lean on stuff (you know.. when you put the BIG pipe on it!), my experience is the drive square is the most likely thing to fail if you are using a 6 point socket.

This is all for personal use.
 
#13 ·
As someone who works on cars/trucks and small engine stuff, I have a lot of Snap On and Mac, but because I only use 3/4" drive occasionally, I just have a cheaper set( Princess Auto - similar to Harbour Freight). I've had this set for years and it has been just fine. Likely if I was using them every day I might feel the need to have something better. Strangely, my 1/2 impact sockets are cheaper as well, and though used daily I have never had to replace one.

Having to it all over, there are some Snap On etc. that I would have just bought something cheaper.
 
#14 ·
We have a shop that repairs a fleet of small heavy equipment (D5 dozer is our largest) and several semis and trailers. Our 3/4" and 1" sets are all from Sunex. Some is Taiwan, some is China. We've yet to break a single one, even using non-impacts in our impact guns. I get the desire to buy USA, but I just can't justify it for the limited use the sockets get. My smaller stuff is all Gear Wrench and Channel Lock. We've had great luck with those too. My son went to school for aircraft mechanics and bought a full set of smaller Snap-On tools for that. He works for me now and his tools are in our shop. They are super nice, particularly the ratchets, but we haven't bought any more of them due to the cost.
 
#17 ·
I only have 1/2 drive that goes up to 32mm and 1.25" . It was a set that I bought from Canadian Tire for ~$250 which they still sell once a year for ~$300.

My biggest socket is 36" and still 1/2 drive, although I it has plenty of pipe wrench marks from having to use a 4' pipe to get enough torque.

For years I would borrow any 3/4 drive sockets from a neighbour. They were standard sized Grey sockets piled into a bucket, and I only used them to drive larger seals lol
 
#21 ·
I have this Neiko impact-rated set that I’ve had for years and it has held up great and seems to be built well, for the cost. Again, maybe not as good as Snap-on but much cheaper and still a great quality impact set.
I’ve used my Milwaukee 1/2” Impact wrench (1,400 ft lbs.) and they have held up just fine to it.
I don’t know if they make a set that goes up as large as you need though.
 
#22 ·
I have this Neiko impact-rated set that I’ve had for years and it has held up great and seems to be built well, for the cost. Again, maybe not as good as Snap-on but much cheaper and still a great quality impact set.
I’ve used my Milwaukee 1/2” Impact wrench (1,400 ft lbs.) and they have held up just fine to it.
I don’t know if they make a set that goes up as large as you need though.