Craigslist Ad says, it's suppose to be a 1971 - 72 Ski-Doo Rotax 335 Cylinder, or is it a 340 TNT Cylinder? It looks to have better Porting than some 335 Cylinders I have seen.
Good luck with that.....I bought a 335 .080" off eBay the other day.
Yep, my bad, the one I bought is: NEW NOS SNOWMAX PISTON KIT 09-746-04 SKI-DOO 335 Olympique 1969-1973 .040 OVER.Good luck with that.....
So...... Max Carb selectionWhat do you figure a 340 TNT Cylinder can handle for Max Carb Size? With the 335/340 TNT Intake Ports both 47mm Wide, could they be made a little Wider? Any Pro's/Con's on doing that?
https://ncalculators.com/area-volume/circle-calculator.htmSo...... Max Carb selection
If you have ever heard the the phrase "time-area" of ports - you know that most books get very detailed about how to figure it etc. Short version of the story - for PISTON PORT intakes.
When the engine is running the the piston bottom edge starts with just a little slit of the port open. On its way up its always uncovering more and more of the port. At TDC the port is fully open.
On the way down - the opposite thing happens. Port starts wide open gets smaller and smaller till closed completely. The only part of the port that is open the entire time? - that very first little slit.
SO...... what you have is a full sized port for only a few milliseconds - and some smaller port the rest of the time. That is the whole time-area discussion - trying to determine the average size of the port during the time it is open.
Why is it important? - because if you "over-carb" low end response suffers and engines get hard to start. Even today if you walk the pits at vintage sled races, you will see sleds being started with Squirt bottles of fuel. Loved the Citation 3500's with primers ...
Luckily for rectangular ports the math is kinda simple and some typical numbers have been generated over the years for carb selection. The following effective port size guidelines are common. Your milage may vary .....
RACING - 100% of physical port area - racers want most possible even if port is fully open only a short time. Best top end power - poor low end
HOT TRAIL riding - 75% physical port area - good top end power and reasonable mid range
REGULAR trail - 65% physical port area - good low end and mid range power
For the 335 it amounts to: So for the Stock 5500rpms. Maybe just Bore Intake for a 36mm Carb is probably best for 75% Hot Trail Sled.
Total window area ..... 335 - 26.5x47 = 1246 sq mm
1246 x 65% = 809 = 32mm circle - Stock 335 carb.
1246 x 75% = 935 = 34.5mm circle
1246 x 100% = 1246 = 39+mm circle
If 335 Intake Port widened to 65% 26.5mm x 50.7mm = 1343.55sq mm for maybe higher 6500+rpms. Using Chart below, it's best to round up.
1343.55 x 65% = 873.3 = 34mm
1343.55 x 75% = 1007.7 = 36mm
1343.55 x 100% = 1343.6 = 38mm Max Size a Standard 335 Cylinder can handle!
TNT 340 For the Stock 6500rpms.
Total window area ..... 29x47 = 1363 sq mm
1363 x 65% = 886 = 33.6 mm
1363 x 75% = 1022 = 36 mm - Tillys come in two sizes 32 and 38. So 38 used.
1363 x 100% = 41+ mm circle -
If TNT Intake Port widened to 65% 29mm x 50.7mm = 1470.3sq mm for higher 6500+rpms. Using Chart below, it's best to round up.
1470.3 x 65% = 955.7 = 35mm
1470.3 x 75% = 1102.7 = 38mm
1470.3 x 100% = 1470.3 = 44mm
Back in the day racers bored to Tillys larger than 38. I have one bored to 40. Heard of bigger.
Now just practical experience from one lungers at the race track - On short tracks guys running 38s have better hole shots - and come out of the corners better. 44's have better top end at the end of the straight on long tracks
There are three basic durations in an engineI was rereading from the beginning of this thread. How did you figure these 335 Oly - 340 TNT at 135/145 Port Durations? Isn't that based on the Exhaust Port Spec's, Rod Length, Port Height from BDC?
I haven't measured my 335 Cylinder yet but 135 duration would mean a 17.1673mm Ex Port Height, a 145 duration would mean a 19.7391mm Ex Port Height.
Port Timing Duration
http://www.csgnetwork.com/timingportdurationcalc.html
Ok, Intake Duration, just wanted to be sure. I did a paper rub and came up with 27 x 50 for this Cylinders Intake Port. I didn't get any Photo's yet. I got the Piston with the Cylinder so I had something to look at. Earlier you Posted a Photo of the Piston notched on the bottom. I noticed when this Piston is at TDC the Intake Port was still partily covered by the Skirt maybe a 1/4", wouldn't you want to open that area up to be closer to the Top of the Intake Port to un-restrict it? I had traced it's Outline onto the Piston Skirt to measure later, but it rubbed off from some of the Oil I had sprayed on the cylinder. I have seen some 2 Strokes where they trim the bottom of the Piston Skirt. For the most part it looked pretty good just some minor cleanup to match stuff up.There are three basic durations in an engine
Exhaust Port Duration - degrees bettween exhaust port opening and closing
Intake Port Duration degrees bettween intake port opening and closing
Transfer Port Duration - degrees bettween transfer ports opening and closing
You can change any one of them independently of the other. (To a point)
Way back in Post #5 you you started quoting CFM and carb numbers. I have been talking about INTAKE duration ever since because that is what you need to know to properly size a carb.
We have not started any discussion on exhaust yet. 135/145 are intake numbers not exhaust.
The calculator you showed is for EXHAUST duration. The measurements would get you to the top of the exhaust port measured from BDC - Doesn't work for intakes.
PLUS - I don't like the BDC view of the ports - Virtually impossible to get close without an assembled engine. No reference point is available for BDC unless the engine is assembled.
When SPITBALLING an engine - I prefer TDC calculations. That way you can measure from the top of the cylinder - at least top of cylinder is close to TDC. All you need is a piston and cylinder to get approximate numbers.
For EXHAUST duration - measure from top of cylinder to top of exhaust port. Convert to degrees Then 360 - (2 x degrees) = Exhaust duration
http://www.torqsoft.net/piston-position.html
For INTAKE duration - slide piston into cylinder until skirt reaches bottom of intake port (just closed). Measure top of cylinder to top edge of piston. Convert to degrees Degrees x 2 = intake duration.
So yes you can figure durations by measuring, knowing rod lengths etc.
BUT - just like determining the CCs of a head - you need to MEASURE the degrees of an engine to be sure what you really have. Base gasket thickness , piston design etc can change intake /exhaust durations.
I know you can create a degree wheel with your CAD program. For years I used a simple degree wheel printout pasted to an old CD - the hole in the middle makes for a convenient place to put a bolt to fasten to the crank.
http://www.modelflying.co.uk/news/article/the-engine-lab-two-stroke-degree-wheel/2349/
Do yourself a favor before you start cutting your cylinder. When you get your short block start taking real measurements for the cylinder you want to modify.
.
Port rubs work ok for duration (height of port)Using Paper Rubs and a Clear Plastic Ruler I came up with these measurements.
My 335 Cylinder #813-010
Intake ID Outside: 35mm
Exhaust ID outside: 40mm
Top of Cylinder to Top of Centerline of Exhaust Port: 45mm
Exhaust Port ID: 26mm x 50mm
Intake Port ID: 27 x 50
Piston Skirt: 75mm
Piston Dome Height: 4mm
Dome Height 4mm x 78mm Bore = 9.6cc
Do you want to trim the piston ? Yes and MaybeOk, Intake Duration, just wanted to be sure. I did a paper rub and came up with 27 x 50 for this Cylinders Intake Port. I didn't get any Photo's yet. I got the Piston with the Cylinder so I had something to look at. Earlier you Posted a Photo of the Piston notched on the bottom. I noticed when this Piston is at TDC the Intake Port was still partily covered by the Skirt maybe a 1/4", wouldn't you want to open that area up to be closer to the Top of the Port to un-restrict it? I had traced it's Outline onto the Piston Skirt to measure later, but it rubbed off from some of the Oil I had sprayed on the cylinder. I have seen some 2 Strokes where they trim the bottom of the Piston Skirt. For the most part it looked pretty good just some minor cleanup to match stuff up.
Ok, that makes since measuring across, but if 47mm Wide across aren't we basing the 65% rule on the Radius of the 78mm Bore? If 47mm Wide which should equal about 74.33deg, a 50mm Wide Port would equal about 79.6deg.Port rubs work ok for duration (height of port)
But they don't work for width of port the way you are describing. When you lay the paper flat and measure you get the Arc length- not the Chordal length See below for difference.
Early on - I used a toothpick for measuring width. Keep making it smaller with a nail clipper, until it just fits into the port. Then measure it with a ruler, micrometer, whatever you have.
Now I use an old inside caliper I found at a rummage sale.
Yea, I was thinking about that last night. I was putting the Dome at TDC. I had a piece of Clear Plastic left over from my Glass Bead Cabinet fix, and I layed it on the work bench with Cylinder upside down and just pushed Piston down till hit the Plastic, then looked at it. I was originally thinking if I could CC the Piston Dome area with the Clear Plastic and Piston that way and never made the adjustment. I was in a hurry, my TV Show was coming on. I need to put Piston Edge at TDC and then look at again to see if it clears the Intake Port. I have one of them Inside Calipers also, but I can't find it now. Need to clean the Shop up. If the Dome is 4mm = 0.1574798" High, I would think the Skirt still covers the Intake Port a little if when Piston Dome is at TDC, roughly 1/4" was blocking the Port, but I'll double check it. My New Pistons came today also, so maybe I can compare Pistons also.Do you want to trim the piston ? Yes and Maybe
Yes - if the piston hangs down in the cylinder it is restricting flow so trimming would help that.
Maybe - Trimming will shorten intake duration. Go back and read the stuff about intake duration. More duration results in reduced low end power and spit back though the carbs.
So MAYBE you can trim the piston - just need to understand what it will do to duration and if you can live with the side effects
BTW - How are you determining TDC with the piston - Top of dome at top of cylinder - or side of piston edge at top of cylinder ?
With edge at top of cylinder, (dome above) my aftermarket piston completely clears the intake
65% guideline for port width is based on bore diameter - (not radius)Ok, that makes since measuring across, but if 47mm Wide across aren't we basing the 65% rule on the Radius of the 78mm Bore? If 47mm Wide which should equal about 74.33deg, a 50mm Wide Port would equal about 79.6deg.
Ok. Got this Piston at TDC now and it doesn't block the Intake Port now. Also Piston at BDC flush with Exhaust Port.65% guideline for port width is based on bore diameter - (not radius)
78mm bore = 100%
78mm bore x 65% = 50.7mm chordal width
47mm wide port calculates as.. 47mm/78mm = 60.3% of Bore diameter.